We Must Retake Osgiliath #127
Retakes...
The bass for "Seek It" and "Across the Park" have been bugging me for more than a week now, because they simply weren't on the beat. However, when I laid it down, it was tight as a fish's crap-factory. I'll explain:
The original process laid out for this recording of the album was that we would record some drums, get samples of them, then make a sort of patchwork drum track out of them. When it was discovered that we might not have enough time for that (partially due to time squandered), we decided to go for a more live sound, which Bones was happy about. So we laid down the first four tracks, being "Gov't Song", "Seek It", "Across the Park" and "My Yesterdays", and then "Sittin on a Rock" a bit after that.
When I did the bass for those songs, I was fairly tight (after a few precioussss moments, brought on by, I suppose, misunderstandings). However, the problem was that the drums made some slight tempo shifts. This just happens, because following a click track (a metronome for recording) is really tough, and besides which, Bones plays totally by feel, meaning that he responds to his environment. This leads to some tempo shifts, but you usually never notice -- until, that is, you put it next to a click track and compare the two. An interesting thing about this is that most people were quick to think that the click track must have gone out of tempo (not bloody likely) before thinking that human fallability might play a part. It's not Bones's fault, it's just a tough thing to do, and we simply didn't have time to dick around and get it right.
So Christian initiated a change, which was to take some samples from those drum tracks and make a sort of patchwork drum track from those samples -- exactly what Jono had laid out at the start of the process. This solved almost every problem, because the drums were suddenly on the tempo without any unexpected shifts, and it sounded great. Bones, I think, might not have been happy about that, but he's being a trooper about it, and I think it also helps that he's laying down a fair few keyboard tracks as well.
But one problem remained, and that was the bass. Because it was tight with the VariSpeed track, it was suddenly not tight at all with the new sampled tracks. But it was close enough that most people didn't make a thing out of it. I noticed mostly because it's my work, and I want it to sound good, but it's also because when something's only very slightly out, it can be more noticeable than if it's way out.
I sat on it for over a week, but it never improved, so I decided, the hell with it, I'm gonna redo it, and since there was no one here this morning but Jono, Christian and myself, it was the perfect opportunity. So the bass on the album should be fairly tight without being some over-produced, mega-quantized piece of pop cynicism -- with the possible exception of "Sittin on a Rock": although it went through the same process described above, it was such a nice bass take that I want to keep it, and it's not so noticeable that I might be able to get away with it.
Yes, Osgiliath was overrun, but unlike Faramir, my retake was a successful campaign. And sometimes I talk some real shite!
keeponrockin
Tom Hauville
Juicy Mountain Bass Monster
